The Agency The Agency

John Caulfield

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
After spending 15 summers vacationing in Montauk, John and his family decided to make the move permanent, and haven’t looked back. John’s easygoing personality and Wall Street finance background well-equips him to provide expert guidance to his buyer, seller, and investor clients.

John has over a decade of experience as a futures trader and co-founded a proprietary trading firm on Wall Street. This extensive experience gives him an advantage in buying and selling homes and predicting sound investments. It was John’s personal experiences with investing that led him to real estate. When he began to make property investments in Aspen, Colorado – where he lived for more than a decade – he discovered his passion for real estate.

Since moving to New York from Aspen, John, his wife, Jen, and their two young sons enjoy their daily beach life in Ditch Plains, where they live. John and Jen have become involved in the community, where their sons go to the local Montauk school, and John coaches East Hampton Little League. You can find John playing 105 tennis, golfing at the Downs, or on the water with his family. His family is frequently in Aspen, where they ski, snowboard, golf, and are members of the Snowmass Club.
The Whitman Team

John's Listings

Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Floor plan of Unit
Floor plan of Unit
Satellite of Unit
Map of Unit
Central Park South, Manhattan, NY
$2,799,000
1 BD, 1 BA, 808 SQFT, condo
listing courtesy of The Agency
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Floor plan of Unit
Satellite of Unit
Map of Unit
in contract
West Village, Manhattan, NY
$1,995,000
2 BD, 2 BA, co-op
listing courtesy of The Agency
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Satellite of Unit
Map of Unit
in contract
New York, NY
$1,975,000
4 BD, 4 BA, 2,500 SQFT, single-family
listing courtesy of The Agency
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Floor plan of Unit
Satellite of Unit
Map of Unit
Lenox Hill, Manhattan, NY
$1,495,000
2 BD, 2 BA, co-op
listing courtesy of The Agency
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Satellite of Unit
Map of Unit
in contract
East Hampton, NY
$1,170,000
3 BD, 2 BA, 1,300 SQFT, single-family
listing courtesy of The Agency
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Floor plan of Unit
Satellite of Unit
Map of Unit
in contract
Park Slope, Brooklyn, NY
$1,150,000
2 BD, 1 BA, 900 SQFT, co-op
listing courtesy of The Agency
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Floor plan of Unit
Satellite of Unit
Map of Unit
in contract
Bedford-Stuyvesant, Brooklyn, NY
$875,000
2 BD, 1 BA, 743 SQFT, condo
listing courtesy of The Agency
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Floor plan of Unit
Satellite of Unit
Map of Unit
Central Harlem, Manhattan, NY
$625,000
2 BD, 1 BA, condop
listing courtesy of The Agency
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Floor plan of Unit
Satellite of Unit
Map of Unit
Sutton Place, Manhattan, NY
$565,000
1 BD, 1 BA, co-op
listing courtesy of The Agency
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Floor plan of Unit
Satellite of Unit
Map of Unit
Lenox Hill, Manhattan, NY
$475,000
1 BD, 1 BA, co-op
listing courtesy of The Agency
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Satellite of Unit
Map of Unit
East Hampton, NY
$200,000
4 BD, 2.5 BA, 3,000 SQFT, single-family
listing courtesy of The Agency
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Satellite of Unit
Map of Unit
Montauk, NY
$160,000
4 BD, 3 BA, 4,000 SQFT, rental property
listing courtesy of The Agency
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Satellite of Unit
Map of Unit
Montauk, NY
$75,000
6 BD, 8 BA, 7,300 SQFT, single-family
listing courtesy of The Agency
Satellite of Unit
Map of Unit
Montauk, NY
$70,000
4 BD, 2.5 BA, 3,000 SQFT, single-family
listing courtesy of The Agency
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Satellite of Unit
Map of Unit
East Hampton, NY
$65,000
3 BD, 2 BA, 1,800 SQFT, rental property
listing courtesy of The Agency
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Satellite of Unit
Map of Unit
Montauk, NY
$65,000
4 BD, 4 BA, 3,400 SQFT, single-family
listing courtesy of The Agency
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Satellite of Unit
Map of Unit
Montauk, NY
$40,000
4 BD, 2 BA, 2,500 SQFT, single-family
listing courtesy of The Agency
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Satellite of Unit
Map of Unit
East Hampton, NY
$20,000
3 BD, 2.5 BA, 2,800 SQFT, single-family
listing courtesy of The Agency
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Satellite of Unit
Map of Unit
East Hampton, NY
$20,000
4 BD, 4.5 BA, 4,100 SQFT, single-family
listing courtesy of The Agency
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Satellite of Unit
Map of Unit
East Hampton, NY
$20,000
5 BD, 5.5 BA, 3,000 SQFT, single-family
listing courtesy of The Agency
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Satellite of Unit
Map of Unit
Amagansett, NY
$20,000
2 BD, 2 BA, 868 SQFT, single-family
listing courtesy of The Agency
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Floor plan of Unit
Satellite of Unit
Map of Unit
Central Park South, Manhattan, NY
$8,500
1 BD, 1 BA, condo
listing courtesy of The Agency
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Photo of Unit
Floor plan of Unit
Satellite of Unit
Map of Unit
Flatbush, Brooklyn, NY
$2,800
1 BD, 1 BA, condo
listing courtesy of The Agency

John's Transaction History

Address Type
24 Ezekills Hollow Sold
225 East Lake Drive Sold
32 Old Montauk Highway Sold
152 Hands Creek Rd Sold
2 Homeward Lane Sold
300 Hill Street Sold
9 Willis Point Rd Sold
29 Georgica Woods Ln Sold
95 Old Farm Road Sold
21 Prospect Boulevard Sold
76 Cove Hollow Road Sold
6 Winterberry Ln Sold
68 S Essex St Sold
11 Glendale Drive Sold
4 N Farragut Road Sold
56 Sandy Hollow Rd Sold
33 Wheelock Walk Sold
4 Fort Pond Road Sold
55 S Euclid Avenue, #3B Sold